The Environmental Journal of Southern Appalachia

In the existential battle between Smokies swine and salamanders, the hogs have the upper hand

Written by

wild hogEfforts to eradicate wild hogs, which have a damaging effect on salamanders and other communities in the Great Smokies, have been ongoing with mixed success for decades. National Archives

Researchers quantify the effects of feral hogs on Smokies salamander populations

GATLINBURG — A recent study investigating the relationship between Great Smoky Mountains National Park’s beloved salamanders and its hated hogs concluded that the rooting of feral pigs decreases the abundance and diversity of Smokies salamanders.

Alexander Funk of Eastern Kentucky University said the effects of feral hogs on salamanders from the family plethodontidae were mixed and varied depending on the season.

Generally, across seasons and especially in the summer, the hogs’ foraging seemed to hurt salamander abundance and diversity. Funk is a student under Eastern Kentucky University’s Director for the Division of Natural Areas Stephen Richter but had help from Benjamin Fitzpatrick of the University of Tennessee at Knoxville. The study involved Funk going out late at night on Balsam Mountain in the spring, summer and fall of 2022.

The study was presented as part of the Discover Life in America 2023 Colloquium, a virtual conference in which researchers in different fields presented. A video of the talk is available on YouTube. Hellbender Press previously reported on the colloquium.

“I think that our results are important for conservation. I think that they could potentially drive conservation in the park via selective management of hogs at high elevations,” Funk told his virtual audience.

Feral hogs, the ancestors of which escaped from hunting preserves in the early 20th century, are invasive and widespread across the Southeastern United States. Great Smoky Mountains National Park has long targeted the hogs with traps and contract hunters.

The study looked at the salamanders at a “patch-scale,” meaning in small areas, but the hogs root “extensively” at higher elevations across the Smokies, Funk said.

“They actually root about 80 percent of all hardwood forest in the park each year when they come up to high elevations to forage,” he said. He said this rooting tends to disrupt the upper soil layer, understory plant cover and leaf litter. Plethodontids use the leaf litter and understory plants as shelter. So the hog disruptions are likely to affect these salamanders.

He also said he’d been analyzing hog stomachs to see if the hogs ate the salamanders directly rather than just affecting their habitats.

“They eat salamanders, but not that frequently,” he said. He said salamander mortality was more likely due to environmental conditions caused by the disruption of habitat.

Overall, Funk said, his studies seemed to show that the hogs’ foraging lowered plethodontids’ abundance and diversity. He said there were at times positive effects for the salamanders, but these positive effects were either short term or likely associated with how easy the salamanders were to see rather than whether they were present. 

He said that the visible hog disturbance did not seem to affect the abundance of plethodontid salamanders in the spring “which is not surprising given that rooting really becomes intense in the late spring into the summer.” He said it affects them more strongly in the summer. 

In the fall he said, hog foraging seemed to have a positive effect on the abundance of plethodontids observed. He said he suspected that this effect might not actually mean there were more of the salamanders, however.

“Hogs increase soil moisture, which increases the probability that you see a salamander on a plot and not the probability of a salamander actually being on a plot,” he said regarding this fall effect.

His studies also looked at the diversity of plethodontid species. 

In the spring the areas the hogs disturbed had less diversity of plethodontids, which seemed to be related to the loss of understory plants. In the summer, however, uprooted plots seemed to have more plethodontid diversity. Still, the patches that were undisturbed last year had more diversity than areas that were not. He said the temporary increase in diversity could be associated with the salamanders using the disturbed areas as a route through which to walk rather than a place to live. His chart showed little effect in the fall on diversity. 

He concluded overall that the trends across seasons might mask variation between seasons, but the inverse might also be true that seasonal variation could also obscure cross-seasonal trends.

He said long-term effects over decades was something that his study had not covered.

Rate this item
(1 Vote)

Related items

  • The Mingus music mill: Tracing a mountain family’s history from slavery to stardom
    in News

    Charles Mingus Jr. 1976, cropped Charles Mingus, the descendant of slaves from the Smokies, is shown chomping a cigar and playing bass at the U.S. Bicentennial celebration in Lower Manhattan, July 4, 1976. Creative Commons Mark Tom Marcello 

    Smokies African American studies trace a great musician with roots in Oconaluftee 

    GATLINBURG ­— Black history, let alone jazz history, isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when most people think about the Smokies.

    But famed jazz musician Charles Mingus Jr.’s family has roots in what is now Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

    At the recent virtual Discover Life in America Colloquium, previously reported on by Hellbender Press, Appalachian Highlands Science Education Coordinator Antoine Fletcher was the sole presenter on social sciences. He went into the Mingus family history and Black history in the Southern Appalachian region.

    Fletcher said the Mingus story derives from the African American Experiences in the Smokies Project, which he described as “a project that is focusing on the untold stories of African Americans in the park and the Southern Appalachian region.”

    “There’s a huge story to tell,” he said of his research. “There are stories of the human vestiges that we have from 900-plus years.”

  • From soil to sky: Will the misty microclimates of the Smokies prevail in a warming world?
    in News

    IMG 7863With the help of GPS coordinates and survey flags, Jordan Stark is able to deploy and locate the exact off-trail placement of soil moisture sensors she placed in Great Smoky Mountains National Park as part of her graduate research at Syracuse University.  Elan Young/Hellbender Press

    Foundational ecology moves from before times to nowadays in the Smokies

    GATLINBURG — In the Middle Ages, salamanders were thought to come from fire. A log set on the hearth would send them scurrying out of the rotten wood, startling those who had gathered around for warmth. We now know that salamanders, of course, come from water — even the European fire salamander with its flame-like yellow markings.

    Over the last 20 years of getting my boots soggy in Great Smoky Mountains National Park, I know these creatures to thrive in the clean, shallow streams and trickles of this temperate rainforest, where annual precipitation is higher than anywhere in the U.S. save for the Pacific Northwest.

    One way to become acquainted with the park is through the water that veins through the hills and is transmuted into vapor that floats on the air in misty silence. After a rain, you can slake your thirst from the pools formed in the creases of broad rhododendron leaves. Sit by a shallow, fishless stream for long enough and you might spot the quick movement of a salamander tail, maybe a flash of orange or brown, or notice a tiny black amphibian face peeking out from behind a smooth stone in the creek.

  • 2016 Smokies wildfires: Six years later, the good and the bad come into focus as natural recovery continues
    in News

    COVER 1208 GatlinburgsInferno1Journalists and park officials document damage from the November 2016 wildfires that killed at least 15 people and left hundreds of dwellings and businesses in ruins. Thomas Fraser/Hellbender Press via Knoxville Mercury

    How the 2016 Great Smoky Mountains National Park wildfire affected salamanders and other life, six years on

    GATLINBURG  The disastrous Chimney Tops 2 wildfire of 2016 occurred some six years ago, but researchers are still looking at its ecological effects.

    The Discover Life in America 2023 Colloquium brought together researchers this month from different fields and universities to present findings on research in Great Smoky Mountains National Park. 

    Researchers presented on many topics, ranging from trout to the history of the Mingus family in the park.

    One such presentation, the first of the day, from William Peterman, associate professor in wildlife ecology and management at Ohio State University, focused on the effects wildfires had on salamander populations, which he described as negative.

    Other presenters touched on the wildfire’s effects as well, including its effects on vegetation and its beneficial effects on the diversity of bird species.

    “Smoky Mountains is the self-proclaimed salamander capital of the world,” Peterman said. He focused his study on the plethodontid family of salamanders, which breathe through their skin.

    “Kind of think of them as a walking lung,” he said.

  • Hunters are invited to go whole hog on the Tennessee side of Big South Fork

    Big South Fork wild hogsWild hogs are seen rooting in a sensitive area. Hog season opens later this month in Big South Fork.  National Park Service

    ONEIDA — Big South Fork National River and Recreation Area this week announced regulations for those wanting to kill invasive wild hogs during the 2022 fall and winter seasons.

    Most hog populations within the protected areas of BSF are believed to be present on the Tennessee side of the park, which spans the Kentucky border. Feral hogs have been present in East Tennessee for generations. They destroy local flora and fauna mainly by rooting in low-lying mountain and valley areas. They are especially fond of salamanders, many species of which are in grave decline. In Great Smoky Mountains National Park, hunters are regularly deployed to cull hogs throughout the park.

    “The wild hog is an invasive exotic species that has a significant negative impact to native species and do a great deal of damage to farmlands and residential areas. The damage they cause threatens park resources including federally listed plants,” according to a release from the park service. 

  • Zigging and zagging to find the Zigzag
    in News

    Zigzag salamander UT doctoral student Bryce Wade examines a Southern zigzag salamander he found at Ijams Nature Center in South Knoxville. Keenan Thomas/Hellbender Press

    On the happy herping trail: Bryce Wade searches for salamanders

    KNOXVILLE — Bryce Wade scours the nature trail, turning over rocks and logs. On this overcast day at Ijams Nature Center, he searches beneath the leaves on the ground for one creature: salamanders.

    Underneath the rocks, logs and leaves, salamanders populate the cool, moist earth, avoiding the sun whenever they can. Wade is looking for a particular type: a winter species informally called the Southern zigzag salamander (Plethodon ventralis). 

  • Naturalists have documented 77 new species in Smokies since 2011
    in News
    Celithemis elisa femaleThe calico pennant dragonfly (Celithemis elisa) is among 77 new species discovered in Great Smoky Mountains National Park over the last decade. Wikipedia Commons

    Apps and public research help uncover new layers of life in Southern Appalachia

    This article was originally published by Smoky Mountain News.

    Visitors armed only with a free app and love of nature have documented more than 4,000 species in Great Smoky Mountains National Park since 2011, according to the nonprofit Discover Life in America, including 77 not previously documented in the park by anyone else. 

    DLiA, which manages the All Taxa Biodiversity Inventory project that aims to catalogue all species residing in the extremely diverse park, recently analyzed more than 71,000 records from the app, iNaturalist, to discover the impact these casual observations have made on the project. 

  • Public biological survey searches for the Smokies most-wanted species
    in News

    Photo by Valerie PolkA child snaps a photo of a flower beetle on a wild hydrangea in Great Smoky Mountains National Park.  Valerie Polk

    Grab your phone and get to some citizen science

    Rhonda Wise writes for the public affairs office of Great Smoky Mountains National Park

    Discover Life in America (DLiA), the nonprofit science research partner, is inviting the public to participate in the Smokies Most Wanted program. This initiative allows visitors to help preserve park species by recording sightings of animals, plants, and other organisms from their smartphones using the iNaturalist app. 

  • Amorous salamanders heat up the Southern winter

    hellbenderhrRob Hunter/Hellbender Press

    Knox News: Winter a key time in salamander reproductive calendar

    The woods, fields, rivers, creeks and wetlands of Southern Appalachia aren’t as barren as one would think in the midst of winter.

    News Sentinel science reporter Vincent Gabrielle gives a solid rundown of why some of our amphibious denizens, including hellbenders, put themselves out there when so many other Appalachian critters retreat to burrows, dens and nests when the snow begins to blow.

    “There are more salamander species that call the Southern Appalachians home than any other place on Earth. There are 30 salamander species present in Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Out of the 550 known salamander species on the planet, 77 live here in our backyards. Their bright colors make them the living jewels of Appalachia,” Gabrielle reports.